Advise on Logo's

*JK*

19th Title Here we Come
Joined
Apr 10, 2009
Messages
4,142
Reaction score
0
Points
0
I have been trying to make a new set of logo's what the vast majority of people shall endure.


Can I have feedback on these please

Style one
ManchesterUnited-2.png

Style Two
jf.png

Style Three
BlackburnRovers.png

Style Four
AstonVilla.png

Style Five
rangers.png
 
Last edited:
Advice*

i don't like them sorry but my opinion, it looks like you havve just done anything to them at random with no goal to achieve
 
The Everton is the only one that doesn't cause me pain, so I'd go for that.

Edit - You've removed the Everton one, so I'm afraid the rest are dreadful.
 
Last edited:
Think you would be better just creating a pack with no effects on the logo's! ;)
 
Another style

BlackburnRovers.png

Constructive criticism:

That, to me, looks like you printed a logo out from your computer, put it in water and then put it on the radiator. It looks quite bad.

Try glossed effects, glass, or even just changing the dimensions of the logos, so that they are slanted or are going into the distance.

Go onto Google and look at logos or things that have a particular style to them, or something that has not been done before. The ones in the OP and this are not very attractive, and need quite a lot of work.

Also, try bringing out the best things in a logo, i.e. the shading, tone, colour.

Make it stand out most of all.

EDIT-

I myself have never made/attempted at making logos, but I am just trying to point out things that I have seen from previous logos that may help.
 
Rate the ones in the OP.
 
This is hard work, I am trying to create something what people will download?
What do you want in logos?

---------- Post added at 12:54 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:51 AM ----------

What about this,

AstonVilla-1.png
 
Some tips -
- Keep it simple. Everyone will look at a simple logo without a million effects which spoil the logo.
- I am guessing you used bevel/Emboss, and then added a texture. Try lessening the depth of it, it will look better.
- If you use the effects keep them simple.

Out of the ones in the OP, v5 is the best, as it isn't laden with effects, but it is still a long way off releasable.

I do consider myself to know what I am talking about. and I am not going to say they are ****, as it takes time to build up a style.
 
Sorry but the only logo's i will ever download will be Stu's :)
 
This is hard work, I am trying to create something what people will download?
What do you want in logos?

---------- Post added at 12:54 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:51 AM ----------

What about this,

AstonVilla-1.png

5/10

Personally I don't like that style of effect, keep it simple.
 
Don't like any of them. If you put so much effects on them, they won't be recognisable as small logos e.g. on the league table.
 
Liverpool.png


Simple yet effective.
 
sorry to hijack ur thread JK, but is there any logo makers who could let me know how to make my own logo? is there any logo templates for photoshop? ( like the kit templates)

any help much appreciated!!
 
Top