FM-Base Defensive Right of the Year Award

  • Thread starter Sam
  • Start date
  • Replies 43
  • Views 2K

Who has been the best DR in the Prem this year?

  • Total voters
    43
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Sam

Guest
Hey Guys, this thread is the Defensive Right voting thread for the FM-Base TOTY, to choose your winner, vote in the poll above.

The Goalkeeper Result:
Winner: Edwin Van Der Sar - 47 Votes
Runner Up: Pepe Reina - 12 Votes

It was really tight, but Van Der Sar wins.

---------- Post added at 01:30 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:22 PM ----------

My vote is Rafael
 
Due to the fact that I watched plenty of Arsenal games this season and less so of other teams, my decision might lack the necessary information to make the 'correct decision' (If there even is one), but I'd definitely go with Sagna here.
 
Offensively: Rafael

Defensively: Ivanovic

Overall this season: Rafael.
 
My vote is for Rafael although it seems that Fabio has taken his place in the team.
 
to be honest, the rest are ****, what about Corluka or Martin Kelly or Kaboul, Carr, O'Shea?

I would say Sagna as he has played more and made a handful of assists (even though Arsenal have been quite **** again this year) he was pretty good and consistent!

Rafael has been great, even though I am quite sure John has started more games than him.... my vote:

Sagna (as a United supporter as well)
 
Raikan007 said:
to be honest, the rest are ****, what about Corluka or Martin Kelly or Kaboul, Carr, O'Shea?

I would say Sagna as he has played more and made a handful of assists (even though Arsenal have been quite **** again this year) he was pretty good and consistent!

Rafael has been great, even though I am quite sure John has started more games than him.... my vote:

Sagna (as a United supporter as well)
Click to expand...

As a Spurs fan, Kaboul, Corluka, Carr made me lol ;)
 
I went Sagna but I would absolutely love to have went for Micah but yet another season completely marred by injury in his career
 
what I am saying is I think you should put all the players (at least the 1st team starters) so people can vote fairly! just because you think that Corluka or Carr are **** does not mean everyone else will!
 
Raikan007 said:
what I am saying is I think you should put all the players (at least the 1st team starters) so people can vote fairly! just because you think that Corluka or Carr are **** does not mean everyone else will!
Click to expand...

Yeah, I like the idea of having all the starters on the poll.
 
Raikan007 said:
what I am saying is I think you should put all the players (at least the 1st team starters) so people can vote fairly! just because you think that Corluka or Carr are **** does not mean everyone else will!
Click to expand...

I will do that next time, which will save my time anyway :) But, Corluka or Carr wouldn't win, and our aim is to find the best, so it really doesn't matter about the lesser players.
 
Sagna easily. How Rafael is leading I'll never know. Also, Martin Kelly > Glen Johnson.
 
Sam said:
I will do that next time, which will save my time anyway :) But, Corluka or Carr wouldn't win, and our aim is to find the best, so it really doesn't matter about the lesser players.
Click to expand...

Carr has been better than at least 3 of the players that are up on that poll this season, so I'd call those 'lesser players'.

But yeah, try to include all the regulars when it comes to the LB poll.

[COLOR=#00e0]---------- Post added at 02:20 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:19 PM ----------[/COLOR]

Ben said:
Sagna easily. How Rafael is leading I'll never know. Also, Martin Kelly > Glen Johnson.
Click to expand...

Certainly agree with you here, I think Arsenal's poor season (Well, can we even call it that, a **** team finishing 3rd\4th) and Manchester United's good season has blurred people's views. But meh I'm not fussed.
 
Rafael was immense till he got injured. Then Fabio gradually took over. In between it was always O'Shea. Rafael was fantastic and this season he showed what a great talent he is.

Sagna has also had good season but for me Rafael just edged it. I'm bit biased maybe but I love the lad. Twins are immense..
 
Redrup said:
Carr has been better than at least 3 of the players that are up on that poll this season, so I'd call those 'lesser players'.

But yeah, try to include all the regulars when it comes to the LB poll.
Click to expand...

You miss the point, if I put Corluka in there, he wouldn't win and neither will Onuoha, so it doesn't really matter, it is between Sagna, Ivanovic and Rafael really. I will use Raikan's suggestion anyway though.
 
Rafael has been brilliant this season, if he keeps improving at this rate, it won't be long before he's the best RB in the world; ditto for his brother.
 
Sigh, Pantsil, what's he doing their?

I'd say Stephen Carr myself.
 
Sam said:
You miss the point, if I put Corluka in there, he wouldn't win and neither will Onuoha, so it doesn't really matter, it is between Sagna, Ivanovic and Rafael really. I will use Raikan's suggestion anyway though.
Click to expand...

No, you miss my point. You have Cuellar, Johnson and Pantsil in there, 3 players who clearly wouldn't win. So why stop there?
 
If you think Stephen Carr like this post.

---------- Post added at 02:40 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:39 PM ----------
Redrup said:
No, you miss my point. You have Cuellar, Johnson and Pantsil in there, 3 players who clearly wouldn't win. So why stop there?
Click to expand...
Cos it's pointless to do anymore
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Top